20 May 2011

“I have been making believe”: religion in “The Wonderful Wizard of Oz”

There is no clear indication of the religion of the citizens of Oz, be it the Munchkins or Quaddlings or Winkies, but there are powerful figures that substitute gods. If there were a way to represent the state of religious rituality in Baum’s book, it would be polytheism. Multiple powers that take over the country comprise the Witches and Oz himself, who is the most god-like figure. They all are endowed with unusual abilities, and, though they do not have complete control either over their mortality or the fate of their subjects, they are separate from the rest of the creatures in the Land of Oz in an elevated way. Searchers for the hidden meanings might find both religious and antireligious undertones in the book. The yellow brick road might symbolize a religious path to God. The obstacles that travelers encounter on that road could represent the tests to prove the worthiness of all the company before the face of the higher power – Oz. Scholars indicate that the road could be seen akin to Buddhist way to enlightenment. And, indeed, it unites all quests - for home, courage, heart, brain. Another allusion to religion comes from the fact that Oz “the terrible” came from the sky: “I found myself in the midst of a strange people, who, seeing me come from the clouds, thought I was a great Wizard” (Baum, 187). It is interesting that Dorothy came from the sky as well together with the storm, and immediately she was given the title of a Witch. Because of the way she appeared in Oz, it could be assumed about her that it is she who owns the potential of becoming as imaginarily powerful as Oz, but only after completing the chain of obstacles – tests for approval. The final test before the desired outcome is achieved would be from the main figure – to kill the Witch of the West and thus to bring redemption for Dorothy and companions. All divine in “The Wonderful Wizard of Oz” was revealed to be plain and deceptive. The godly figure – Wizard comes down to Earth with a confession “I am a humbug” (Baum, 184). A curious deprecation happens to the evil part of the polytheic pantheon. Wickedness of the Witch of the West is wiped by water as if in a ritual of baptism. The only divine part stays in Glinda, but still it is rather goodness than supernatural that upraises her. So what kind of a conclusion does the reader may come to? Knowing that Baum was a theosophist, it could be assumed that he applied this idea to the book as well, since Dorothy’s quest resembles a quest for “truth”. The details in the book, though, provide examples of self-reliance more than an appeal to God. The only might-be “candidate” for god, the Wizard, simply says: “I have been making believe” (Baum, 184).These words basically summarize the question of religion in the Land of Oz, just like the prejudices of companions about their own incapabilities to use brain, heart and courage. In the whole book, there is not a single mentioning of a word “god”. However, there is a church that is broken – in the china land, which is symbolic of the importance of religion. Literally, Dorothy does not find any damage in destroying a sacred place: I think we were lucky in not doing these people more harm than breaking a cow’s leg and a church” (Baum, 234). There is no god as an entity, but perhaps Baum meant that there is enough of godly power in the self – in Dorothy and her companions. Perhaps, it was all about stopping to turn the sights to the sky that keeps silent after the storm. The question of religion in Oz is open – should there be faith or must there be enough to hold on within the self? Unlike Baum, Gregory Maguire makes a significant accent on religion. The struggle between Pleasure Faith and Unionism poses a moral dilemma of extremes versus modesty. The importance of faith in “Wicked” makes the reader assume that the accent was intended by Maguire to oppose the absence of faith in Baum’s Oz. Thus, “Wicked” promises a clearly depicted faith theme and problem, though it seems like a lot of the questions will still be up to the reader to answer.

8 comments:

  1. I think that you took an interesting perspective on Baum's intentions and subliminal message in The Wizard of Oz. I think that religion can be applied to The Wizard of OZ and how to ties into the characters actions and internal feelings, but I don't know if it really was Baum's intention to have it be a children' story about religion. There is a difference between what an authors intention is and what a reader can apply to a story.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I never thought about The Wizard of Oz as being so religious but yet reading through your blog post I could completely understand all the angles that you were getting at. The yellow brick road especially as a path way to a higher power was really an interesting idea and it really makes a lot of sense. Oz is the highest power in, well, Oz and to him is directly where the yellow brick road leads. You then mentioned how while along the path Dorothy and her companions run into many tasks that they must complete to prove their worthiness before seeing OZ which is another great point. You have a lot of really good insight into The Wizard of Oz and religion and it is a lot of things that most people would not see unless pointed out to them. This is a really good post and it makes so much sense!

    ReplyDelete
  3. This was a really interesting observation and topic within both books. I agree on you're assumption that Oz could be a reference or allusion to God. Though, I do not know how likely that would be since Baum, as you stated, was a theosophist. Also, it seems that there is actually a lot of meaning and symbolism hidden within the Wizard of Oz. This completely contradicts Baum's objective in creating a new "modern fairy tale" for children. It would also be interesting to discover what Maguire's real intention was in creating religion as a prominent problem in his novel.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  5. You raise a lot of good points about religion, or the lack thereof in Oz. For example, I'd never thought about the breaking of the ceramic church in that way, but now that you point it out it does seem to me that Baum could've been trying to send an anti-religious message. You also mentioned how Oz appeared to be semi-godly figure, but his power turned out to be just an illusion, and I believe that this also sends an anti-religious message. Also, in relation to your point about the God within each of the characters, I think this idea really has potential to connect to the plot of the story. Perhaps the God within each of the characters could be the trait they feel they are missing. They seek out the Wizard (the Godly figure)to help them gain these traits, but in the end he really doesn't give them anything they didn't already have- thus the God was already in each of the characters. I realize this idea is a lot of speculation, but it makes sense to me.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Baum’s religion could have influenced The Wizard of Oz, someone’s religion influences every decision they make. Baum was a theosophist; theosophy declares that every religion helps humanity try to achieve perfection so every religion has truth in it. I think that it is interesting that Baum then made the Wizard of Oz deceitful and untruthful. I think this shows Baum’s true feelings toward industry, which is portrayed as a dictatorship in the Emerald City. I think that it is also interesting that Svitlana said that Dorothy is on the journey to truth, I don’t know if she is looking for truth, I don’t know if Kansas represents truth for her, and I don’t think that she is on the pathway to God either. I think that she needs a God-like figure to tell her how to get home.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Svitlana--when one clicks on your "theosophist" link, she is led to a rather unenlightening page. Can you find a more helpful resource to go to for further discussion of the term?

    ReplyDelete
  8. I am sorry I have had a really hard time arranging the post, and by the way still I failed to divide the text into paragraphs though I tried so hard. Here is a link to a very comprehensive site about theosophy, I don't know why the Wikipedia link didn't work: http://theosnet.ning.com/

    ReplyDelete